Preserving Quality: Understanding Shelf Life in Pet Food

As the pet food industry continues to evolve, it is driven by increasingly health-conscious consumers and higher quality standards. Amidst the innovation in ingredients, formulations, and packaging, one essential factor quietly but powerfully shapes every step of production. Regardless of whether it’s crunchy kibble, savory canned food, nutritious treats, or raw diets, the longevity of a product—its ability to remain safe, nutritious, and appealing over time—is critical.  

Shelf life isn’t merely a technical consideration; it’s a commitment to pet safety, product integrity, and brand trust. This article delves into the scientific and operational elements that govern shelf life, including packaging, water activity, moisture control, pH, oxygen control, and testing, while also exploring current industry practices and future opportunities. 

What Is Shelf Life? 

At its core, shelf life is defined as the time span during which a food product maintains its safety, sensory qualities, nutritional value, and meets any label claims. For pet foods, this is particularly important, as spoilage can pose serious health threats due to microbial contamination or nutrient degradation. Beyond the obvious health implications, spoiled pet food also results in economic loss, brand damage, and potential regulatory consequences. Contaminants such as Salmonella or mycotoxins are not just theoretical risks—they represent real dangers that underline the importance of shelf life management. 

Packaging, Water Activity, Oxygen—Oh My! 

One of the first, and perhaps most visible, lines of defense in preserving shelf life is packaging. It serves as a barrier against the many environmental factors that accelerate spoilage, such as moisture, oxygen, light, and microbial intrusion.  

Advances in technology have brought about modern solutions like multi-layer barrier films, which significantly reduce oxygen and water vapor transmission rates. These materials help slow down oxidative damage and microbial growth, thereby prolonging product stability. Modified Atmosphere Packaging (MAP), where inert gases like nitrogen replace oxygen within sealed packages, is another widely adopted method. Some products even use vacuum packaging or oxygen scavengers, which actively remove or bind residual oxygen. These innovations are not just cosmetic upgrades—they are essential, stemming from research-backed strategies that show oxygen-permeable packaging drastically reduces shelf life, particularly for higher-fat foods. 

Another critical yet often misunderstood aspect of shelf life is the distinction between moisture content and water activity. Though they sound similar, they are fundamentally different. Moisture content refers to the total amount of water in a product, both bound and free, while water activity (aw) measures only the free, unbound water that supports microbial growth and enzymatic activity.  

Water activity is a more accurate predictor of spoilage potential. Most bacteria are unable to grow below a water activity of 0.91, and molds and yeasts are generally inhibited below 0.70. Virtually all microbial growth ceases below 0.60. For this reason, dry kibble typically maintains a water activity below this threshold. However, semi-moist treats or moist products often require humectants, like glycerol, to reduce water activity while maintaining the desired texture and mouthfeel through the shelf life of the product. 

pH is another pivotal factor in maintaining shelf stability, particularly for moist and canned foods. A lower pH environment—one that’s more acidic—can inhibit the growth of many spoilage organisms and pathogens. While the FDA considers foods with a pH below 4.6 and a water activity below 0.85 to be shelf stable, some studies suggest that a lower water activity threshold should be used to account for variations in water activity within products. To achieve this balance, pet food manufacturers often turn to natural organic acids such as citric acid, lactic acid, or ascorbic acid. While these compounds are effective in lowering pH and extending shelf life, over-acidification can negatively impact flavor and nutrient stability, so precision in formulation is key. 

Oxygen, though invisible, plays a significant role in the degradation of pet food. It promotes lipid oxidation, which leads to rancidity and off-odors, as well as the breakdown of essential vitamins like A, D, E, and K. Moreover, when combined with high moisture content, oxygen can accelerate microbial spoilage.  

The industry has responded with a range of oxygen control strategies, including the use of natural antioxidants like mixed tocopherols and rosemary extract. While synthetic antioxidants like BHA, BHT, and ethoxyquin have been used historically, some are now falling out of favor due to safety concerns and shifting consumer preferences. Additionally, nitrogen or CO2 flushing, vacuum sealing, and the use of oxygen-absorbing sachets are commonly employed during packaging to reduce residual oxygen and enhance oxidative stability. 

Testing Protocols 

Testing is the cornerstone of ensuring that shelf life predictions hold up under real-world conditions. Manufacturers rely on several methods to validate and monitor product safety over time.  

Accelerated Shelf Life Testing (ASLT) exposes products to elevated temperatures and humidity to simulate long-term aging in a shorter period. Microbiological assays help detect harmful organisms like Salmonella, Listeria, mold, and yeasts. Chemical assays monitor parameters like peroxide values and free fatty acid content, which serve as indicators of lipid oxidation. Organoleptic tests—sensory evaluations of appearance, odor, and palatability—are also crucial, especially for products designed to appeal to both pets and their human buyers. More advanced companies are beginning to adopt real-time shelf life studies to fine-tune predictions based on actual storage conditions, making shelf life a dynamic and data-driven process. 

In recent years, the pet food industry has taken significant steps forward in response to increased scrutiny and a more informed consumer base. Following several high-profile recalls in the early 2000s and 2010s, many manufacturers have implemented rigorous safety protocols. These include Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) plans, Good Manufacturing Practices (GMPs), and enhanced traceability systems that incorporate barcoding and blockchain technologies. Additionally, as demand grows for more natural and “clean label” products, manufacturers are shifting toward natural preservatives and reducing reliance on synthetic additives. Regulatory oversight from agencies like the FDA, AAFCO, and USDA ensures that minimum standards are met, while third-party certifications such as SQF and BRC signify voluntary excellence in quality assurance. 

Ultimately, maximizing shelf life in pet food is a complex interplay of science, technology, and responsibility. From managing water activity and pH to controlling oxygen exposure and conducting thorough testing, every link in the production chain contributes to the overall quality and safety of the final product. As consumer expectations continue to evolve and innovations in ingredients and processing expand, shelf life strategies must keep pace—not merely to prevent spoilage, but to safeguard the health, wellness, and trust of the pets and people who depend on them. 

Partnering for Better Shelf Life Outcomes 

Navigating the complexities of pet food shelf life requires more than just theoretical knowledge—it demands real-world experience, multidisciplinary expertise, and forward-thinking solutions. That’s where BSM Partners comes in. As the largest full-service consulting firm serving the pet industry, BSM Partners helps companies implement science-backed strategies to improve product stability, safety, and quality. From designing effective packaging solutions to optimizing formulations for ideal water activity and pH, our team of veterinarians, food scientists, microbiologists, and regulatory experts supports every step of the product lifecycle.  

With BSM Partners, pet food brands can confidently address shelf life challenges, align with regulatory standards, and deliver safe, high-quality nutrition that meets the expectations of today’s discerning pet owners. 

Follow us on LinkedIn for the latest updates on all things happening here at BSM Partners.

About the Author

Dr. Emily Taylor is Manager of BSM Assurance, BSM Partners' Food Safety, Quality Assurance, and Regulatory Services team. Dr. Taylor is a nutritionist with over 14 years in the animal industry. She resides in Lafayette, Indiana, with her family, showing dressage horses.